SJR 60 – Niche Property tax exemption

PRO-TAXPAYER POSITION
Oppose
Senate Journal Page: 2283

SJR 60 proposes a constitutional amendment that would allow county commissioners courts to exempt from property taxes the portion of a home’s value added by installing a rainwater harvesting or graywater system. While the stated intent is to promote water conservation, the resolution would complicate the tax code by creating a new, selective exemption. Instead of providing broad tax relief, it rewards certain property owners based on their ability to afford and install niche environmental upgrades—an option not available to many Texans. Renters, lower-income homeowners, and those in dense urban areas where space or infrastructure doesn’t allow for these systems would be effectively excluded from any benefit, while still subsidizing the lost revenue through higher rates or reduced services. The policy could result in a patchwork of exemptions across the state, with different counties adopting different rules, undermining consistency and fairness in taxation. Additionally, it opens the door for further politically favored carve-outs, further eroding the principle of equal treatment under the tax code. It also raises enforcement and verification challenges, as local governments would be tasked with confirming installation details, valuation impact, and compliance, all of which add red tape and administrative costs. From a fiscally conservative, pro-taxpayer standpoint, this measure represents government interference in the tax base and picks winners and losers in the marketplace. For these reasons, TFR opposes SJR 60.

PRO-TAXPAYER POSITION
Oppose
Vote Breakdown:
25
6
  • Pro-Taxpayer
  • Anti-Taxpayer
  • Absent
  • Speaker
  • Absent, Excused
  • Present, not voting
  • Not Applicable
LegislatorDistrictPartyVote
Carol Alvarado
6 Democrat
X
Paul Bettencourt
7 Republican
X
Brian Birdwell
22 Republican
X
César Blanco
29 Democrat
X
Donna Campbell
25 Republican
X
Molly Cook
15 Democrat
X
Brandon Creighton
4 Republican
Check
Sarah Eckhardt
14 Democrat
X
Pete Flores
24 Republican
X
Roland Gutierrez
19 Democrat
X
Brent Hagenbuch
30 Republican
Check
Bob Hall
2 Republican
X
Kelly Hancock
9 Republican
Check
Juan Hinojosa
20 Democrat
X
Adam Hinojosa
27 Republican
X
Joan Huffman
17 Republican
X
Bryan Hughes
1 Republican
Check
Nathan Johnson
16 Democrat
X
Phil King
10 Republican
X
Lois Kolkhorst
18 Republican
Check
José Menéndez
26 Democrat
X
Mayes Middleton
11 Republican
Check
Borris Miles
13 Democrat
X
Robert Nichols
3 Republican
X
Tan Parker
12 Republican
X
Angela Paxton
8 Republican
X
Charles Perry
28 Republican
X
Charles Schwertner
5 Republican
X
Kevin Sparks
31 Republican
X
Royce West
23 Democrat
X
Judith Zaffirini
21 Democrat
X