HJR 45 by Shaheen: Property Tax Exemption at Expense of Other Taxpayers

PRO-TAXPAYER POSITION
Oppose
House Record Vote: 293

Ultimately HJR 45 seeks to allow for a local property tax exemption for a physician that provides healthcare services while also not seeking payment for those services from the state and federal Medicaid programs. Exempting one group from a tax only increases the burden on those who do not qualify for such an exemption, unless the spending of the local government levying the tax is simultaneously lowered, thereby lessening the burden. Texas taxpayers absolutely deserve property tax relief but providing an exemption for one group at the expense of another is not the right approach. For these reasons, TFR opposes HJR 45.

PRO-TAXPAYER POSITION
Oppose
Vote Breakdown:
106
39
1
1
1
  • Pro-Taxpayer
  • Anti-Taxpayer
  • Absent
  • Speaker
  • Absent, Excused
  • Present, not voting
  • Not Applicable
LegislatorDistrictPartyVote
Alma Allen
131 Democrat
X
Steve Allison
121 Republican
X
Rafael Anchia
103 Democrat
Check
Charles Anderson
56 Republican
X
Trent Ashby
9 Republican
X
Ernest Bailes
18 Republican
X
Cecil Bell
3 Republican
X
Keith Bell
4 Republican
Check
Diego Bernal
123 Democrat
X
Salman Bhojani
92 Democrat
X
Greg Bonnen
24 Republican
X
Rhetta Bowers
113 Democrat
X
John Bryant
114 Democrat
Check
Brad Buckley
54 Republican
X
John Bucy
136 Democrat
X
Benjamin Bumgarner
63 Republican
X
DeWayne Burns
58 Republican
X
Dustin Burrows
83 Republican
X
Angie Button
112 Republican
X
Briscoe Cain
128 Republican
Check
Liz Campos
119 Democrat
X
Terry Canales
40 Democrat
Check
Giovanni Capriglione
98 Republican
X
Travis Clardy
11 Republican
X
Sheryl Cole
46 Democrat
X
Nicole Collier
95 Democrat
Check
David Cook
96 Republican
X
Philip Cortez
117 Democrat
X
Tom Craddick
82 Republican
X
Charles Cunningham
127 Republican
X
Drew Darby
72 Republican
Check
Yvonne Davis
111 Democrat
Check
Jay Dean
7 Republican
A-EX
Mano DeAyala
133 Republican
X
Mark Dorazio
122 Republican
X
Harold Dutton
142 Democrat
X
Trey Fischer
116 Democrat
PNV
Lulu Flores
51 Democrat
X
James Frank
69 Republican
X
Frederick Frazier
61 Republican
X
Erin Gamez
38 Democrat
X
Josey Garcia
124 Democrat
X
Gary Gates
28 Republican
Check
Stan Gerdes
17 Republican
X
Charlie Geren
99 Republican
X
Barbara Gervin-Hawkins
120 Democrat
X
Craig Goldman
97 Republican
X
Mary González
75 Democrat
Check
Jessica González
104 Democrat
Check
Vikki Goodwin
47 Democrat
X
R.D. Guerra
41 Democrat
X
Ryan Guillen
31 Republican
X
Sam Harless
126 Republican
X
Cody Harris
8 Republican
X
Caroline Harris
52 Republican
X
Brian Harrison
10 Republican
Check
Richard Hayes
57 Republican
Check
Cole Hefner
5 Republican
X
Ana Hernandez
143 Democrat
X
Abel Herrero
34 Democrat
X
Gina Hinojosa
49 Democrat
X
Justin Holland
33 Republican
Check
Donna Howard
48 Democrat
X
Lacey Hull
138 Republican
Check
Todd Hunter
32 Republican
X
Carrie Isaac
73 Republican
Check
Jacey Jetton
26 Republican
X
Julie Johnson
115 Democrat
X
Ann Johnson
134 Democrat
X
Jarvis Johnson
139 Democrat
Check
Venton Jones
100 Democrat
Check
Jolanda Jones
147 Democrat
X
Kyle Kacal
12 Republican
X
Tracy King
80 Democrat
X
Ken King
88 Republican
X
Stan Kitzman
85 Republican
X
Stephanie Klick
91 Republican
X
John Kuempel
44 Republican
X
Suleman Lalani
76 Democrat
X
Stan Lambert
71 Republican
X
Brooks Landgraf
81 Republican
X
Jeff Leach
67 Republican
X
Terri Leo-Wilson
23 Republican
Check
Oscar Longoria
35 Democrat
X
Janie Lopez
37 Republican
X
Ray Lopez
125 Democrat
X
J.M. Lozano
43 Republican
X
John Lujan
118 Republican
X
Christian Manuel
22 Democrat
X
Armando Martinez
39 Democrat
X
Will Metcalf
16 Republican
X
Morgan Meyer
108 Republican
X
Terry Meza
105 Democrat
Check
Joseph Moody
78 Democrat
X
Eddie Morales
74 Democrat
X
Christina Morales
145 Democrat
X
Geanie Morrison
30 Republican
X
Sergio Muñoz
36 Democrat
X
Andrew Murr
53 Republican
Check
Victoria Neave
107 Democrat
Check
Candy Noble
89 Republican
X
Tom Oliverson
130 Republican
X
Angelia Orr
13 Republican
X
Lina Ortega
77 Democrat
X
Jared Patterson
106 Republican
X
Dennis Paul
129 Republican
X
Claudia Perez
79 Democrat
X
Mary Perez
144 Democrat
X
Mihaela Plesa
70 Democrat
X
Walter Price
87 Republican
X
Ana-Maria Ramos
102 Democrat
Check
John Raney
14 Republican
X
Richard Raymond
42 Democrat
X
Ron Reynolds
27 Democrat
Check
Glenn Rogers
60 Republican
X
Ramon Romero
90 Democrat
Check
Toni Rose
110 Democrat
Check
Jon Rosenthal
135 Democrat
X
Matt Schaefer
6 Republican
Check
Nate Schatzline
93 Republican
X
Mike Schofield
132 Republican
X
Matt Shaheen
66 Republican
X
Penny Shaw
148 Democrat
X
Carl Sherman
109 Democrat
Check
Hugh Shine
55 Republican
X
Shelby Slawson
59 Republican
Check
Reggie Smith
62 Republican
X
John Smithee
86 Republican
X
David Spiller
68 Republican
Check
Lynn Stucky
64 Republican
X
Valoree Swanson
150 Republican
Check
James Talarico
50 Democrat
X
Carl Tepper
84 Republican
Check
Shawn Thierry
146 Democrat
Absent
Kronda Thimesch
65 Republican
X
Ed Thompson
29 Republican
X
Senfronia Thompson
141 Democrat
Check
Tony Tinderholt
94 Republican
Check
Steve Toth
15 Republican
X
Ellen Troxclair
19 Republican
X
Chris Turner
101 Democrat
X
Gary VanDeaver
1 Republican
X
Cody Vasut
25 Republican
Check
Hubert Vo
149 Democrat
X
Armando Walle
140 Democrat
Check
Terry Wilson
20 Republican
Check
Gene Wu
137 Democrat
Check
Erin Zwiener
45 Democrat
Check